Penn State’s decision to part ways with James Franklin has sent shockwaves through the college football world, leaving fans and analysts alike wondering: Who will step into one of the most high-pressure coaching roles in the sport? After a stunning eight-day spiral that saw the Nittany Lions suffer humiliating defeats to Oregon, UCLA, and Northwestern, Franklin’s tenure came to an abrupt end—with Penn State absorbing a staggering $45 million buyout. But here’s where it gets intriguing: Athletic Director Pat Kraft’s swift action suggests he already has a shortlist in mind. Let’s dive into the candidates who could reshape Penn State’s future.
Two names immediately rise to the top, both with deep Big Ten roots and local connections. First up is Curt Cignetti, the 64-year-old Pittsburgh native who’s transformed Indiana into a powerhouse. Cignetti’s Hoosiers didn’t just beat Oregon—they dominated, sacking the quarterback six times and scoring 30 points at Autzen Stadium. That’s a statement win Penn State hasn’t seen in years. With a 17-2 record midway through his second season and a College Football Playoff appearance in Year 1, Cignetti is the definition of a splash hire. But there’s a catch: he’d owe Indiana $13 million if he leaves before December 1. And this is the part most people miss—his ability to rebuild programs and change cultures makes him a game-changer for Penn State.
The other frontrunner? Matt Rhule, Kraft’s close friend and current Nebraska head coach. Rhule, a former Nittany Lions linebacker, has deep ties to Happy Valley and a proven track record. He led Temple to back-to-back 10-win seasons, including a 27-10 victory over Penn State in 2015, and turned around Baylor in a challenging situation. Now in his third year at Nebraska, Rhule has steadily improved the Huskers, going 5-1 this season. While he’d owe Nebraska $5 million if he leaves, it’s hard to imagine him turning down his alma mater—or his old boss. But here’s the controversial question: Is Rhule’s loyalty to Kraft a strength or a potential distraction?
If neither Cignetti nor Rhule takes the job, the search gets trickier. Manny Diaz, Duke’s head coach and former Penn State defensive coordinator, is a name to watch. His two-year stint under Franklin left a strong impression, and his work at Miami (21-15 record) and Duke (13-6 overall, 8-3 in ACC play) showcases his ability to lead. Another dark horse? Clark Lea, Vanderbilt’s 43-year-old coach, who’s done remarkable work at his alma mater, leading the Commodores to a bowl game last year and a 5-1 start this season. And let’s not forget Matt Campbell, Iowa State’s 45-year-old leader, who took the Cyclones to their best season ever in 2020. While Campbell’s NFL aspirations are no secret, the Penn State job could be too big to ignore—even for a program that hasn’t won a conference title since 1912.
But here’s the real debate: Does Penn State need a proven winner like Cignetti, a hometown hero like Rhule, or an up-and-comer like Diaz or Lea? And what does this say about the program’s identity moving forward? One thing’s certain: the next coach will inherit a program hungry for success—and a fanbase eager for answers. What’s your take? Who should Penn State hire, and why? Let’s hear it in the comments!
